Mutual Funds

Index Fund vs Mutual Fund: Understanding the Difference & Making the Right Choice

By admin
07 October 2025
4 mins read

Twitter

Facebook

Index Fund vs Mutual Fund: Understanding the Difference & Making the Right Choice

If you’ve ever explored investment options, you may have heard the terms “index fund” and “mutual fund”. At first glance, it may seem like a case of index fund vs mutual fund, but index funds are a type of mutual fund. The real choice here is between passively managed index funds and actively managed mutual funds. Both help you grow wealth over time, but in different ways.

Let’s break down the difference between an index fund and a mutual fund and help you figure out which might fit your financial goals better.

What is a mutual fund?

A mutual fund is an investment option that collects funds from multiple investors and allocates them across a diversified mix of assets, including equities, bonds, and other securities. In India, mutual funds are broadly classified into two categories:

Actively managed funds

These funds are handled by skilled fund managers who analyze markets, study company performance, and actively adjust portfolios to outperform a benchmark index.

Passively managed funds

These funds follow the market index’s performance rather than outperform it. They replicate the index and maintain a portfolio that mirrors its components. Index funds fall into this category.

What is an index fund?

An index fund is a type of mutual fund that passively follows the performance of a market index. These indices can be the Nifty 50 or the Sensex. It invests in the same stocks and in the same proportion as the chosen index. The returns also move in line with the index (minus a small management fee).

Differences between index funds and mutual funds

Here’s a clear look at the index vs mutual fund debate:

Aspect	Index funds	Mutual funds
Management style	Passive index funds replicate an index and don’t need active decisions.	Actively managed mutual funds use research and strategy to try to beat the market.
Costs	Index funds usually have much lower expense ratios.	Actively managed funds can charge comparatively higher fees, since they involve research and frequent trades.
Performance	Index funds aim to match the market. Surprisingly, studies show they often outperform most actively managed funds over the long term.	Actively managed funds may perform better in bullish markets, but achieving consistency is challenging.
Risk	Index funds carry the same risk as the market index they track. For example, a Nifty 50 index fund reflects the fluctuations of the top 50 companies.	Risks in actively managed funds vary depending on the manager’s decisions, sometimes resulting in higher risk and sometimes in more stable returns.
Transparency and simplicity	Index funds are easy to understand. You know exactly what’s inside because it’s tied to the index.	Actively managed funds are more complex, and performance depends on the fund manager’s skill.

Which one should you choose?

The solution to index fund vs a mutual fund depends on various factors.

Goal - Choose index funds for steady, long-term growth. If you wish to achieve higher growth and also have a higher risk appetite, you can choose an actively managed fund.
Cost - If you want to keep your investment cost low, index funds are ideal. Actively managed funds come with a higher management cost, i.e., expense ratio.
Risk appetite - Index funds are conservative investments that help even out risk over the long run. Actively managed funds are exposed to market volatility and are not suitable for risk-averse investors.
Holding duration - Index funds should ideally be held for a longer duration to reap the benefits of long-term market growth fully. Actively managed funds can deliver good returns even in the short and medium term.

The Final Choice

Before choosing either of the two fund types, gain complete clarity on their risk rating, AUM, track record, management, costs, etc. Thereafter, check which one aligns with your investment goals and risk appetite. Be it index funds or actively managed mutual funds, the Tata Capital Moneyfy app makes investing simple, transparent, and convenient.

Compare funds, check their performance, and start investing, all in just a few taps, with the Moneyfy app today!

FAQs

Are index funds better than mutual funds?

It depends on your investment goals. Index funds track specific benchmarks and offer low-cost, steady growth, while mutual funds involve active management that may deliver higher returns, but not always consistently.

Why do people prefer mutual and index funds?

Both offer diversification, professional management, and easy access. For many investors, these features provide a balance of growth and safety compared to managing individual stocks.

Is buying individual stocks better or investing in index funds?

It depends on your risk appetite and knowledge. Stocks give you complete control but require time, research, and a high tolerance for volatility. Index funds spread your money across many companies, making them a safer, hands-off way to invest.

Can mutual funds beat index funds?

Yes, actively managed mutual funds can outperform index funds, especially in rising markets. However, there might be higher fees and frequent trading that make consistent outperformance challenging.

Which is more risky: Mutual funds or index funds?

Mutual funds can be riskier due to active management and concentration in certain assets. Index funds, being diversified and passively managed, carry lower risks.