We help enhance your investment skills

Learning has never been easier

Tata Capital Moneyfy > Blog > NPS > NPS vs annuity plans: Difference between annuity and pension

NPS

NPS vs annuity plans: Difference between annuity and pension

NPS vs annuity plans: Difference between annuity and pension

Deciding on ways to save for your post-retirement life can be daunting. However, planning for retirement ahead of time allows you to enjoy those years in peace. The article below goes over some important details that you should know before deciding which investment choice is best for you. Here is a comparison of annuity plans and NPS.

What is NPS?

The National Pension Scheme (NPS) is a government-run social security programme. All employees of the public, private, and unorganized sectors are eligible to participate in the pension scheme. It encourages people to contribute to an NPS account regularly during their working lives to achieve retirement benefits. When you retire, you will receive a monthly pension based on the amount of money you have saved over time.

What Are Annuity Plans?

An annuity plan is a financial instrument that, following a lump-sum investment, provides you with guaranteed annual payments for the rest of your life. The life insurance company invests your money and then pays you back the profits. You may think of it as a payment paid to you in lieu of a pension.

Difference Between Annuity & Pension Plans

BasisPension planAnnuity
MeaningA retirement corpus built with regular contributions made by you or your employer over a period.An agreement where you pay a lump sum (or part payments) to receive a steady income in the future.
Payment styleContributions are made at fixed intervals by the employee, employer, or bothOne-time lump-sum payment (or multiple premiums)
Offered byNPS, the government, or your employerInsurance companies
Payment timelineAfter retirement, typically between 58 and 60 yearsImmediately (immediate annuity) or in the future (deferred annuity)
Risk liabilityThe employer, pension fund manager, or government is responsible for managing risks.You determine your risk tolerance, as some annuities are market-linked.
Payment receiptMonthly pension or lump-sum withdrawal (60%) + pensionMonthly, quarterly, annually, or lifetime payouts
FlexibilityLowerHigher
Contribution limitMinimum contribution: Rs. 6,000 per yearMinimum contribution: Rs. 18,000 Maximum contribution: Rs. 24,000
Mode of investmentUp to 75% of investments can be made in equityDo not provide pure equity funds
PenaltyYou can reactivate your account by paying a small fee if you fail to pay your NPS contributions.Annuity plans may lapse if you don’t pay premiums on time or within the grace period. Reactivation is possible if you pay all pending premiums during the revival term.
Maturity60% of the corpus can be withdrawn, with the remaining 40% converted to annuity when the NPS achieves maturity.Investors can withdraw only one-third of their capital, with the remainder requiring the purchase of a 66% annuity.
Ideal forPrivate, public, or government-sector employees seeking long-term, predictable retirement incomeRetired individuals desiring a fixed, guaranteed income from the start of their retirement

Purpose & Benefits of Annuities vs. Pensions

Selecting the right financial product is crucial for a smooth and stress-free retirement. Here’s a look at the distinct purposes annuities and pensions fulfill and the benefits they offer to help you secure your financial future.

Annuities

Annuities are designed to convert your savings into a guaranteed income source during retirement. The plans are ideal for those desiring financial certainty and peace of mind. Annuities offer flexible payout options, allowing you to start receiving income immediately or later.

Benefits of annuities

  • Policyholders receive a fixed income for as long as they live.
  • The payout amounts and intervals are pre-determined, leaving no room for financial uncertainty and guaranteeing mental peace.
  • You can choose when you should start receiving the income - immediately or after a few years.
  • With fixed annuities, you’re protected against stock market fluctuations.
  • You can become financially independent, eliminating the need to depend on children or others.

Pensions

Pensions help you create a strong retirement fund through consistent investment habits. It consists of contributions you, your employer, and the government make, which grow over time and guarantee a monthly income after retirement. The plans ensure financial security and stability in the future.

Benefits of pensions

  • Pensions provide a predictable and steady retirement income.
  • It encourages disciplined savings throughout the course of your career.
  • Most pension schemes offer tax advantages under Section 80C/80CCD.
  • Spousal or dependent coverage after the policyholder’s demise is offered with some plans.
  • Pensions reduce the fear of your money running out and guarantee a stress-free future.

Types of Annuities & Pensions

A comparison of annuity vs NPS isn’t complete without understanding the different types of annuities and pensions.

Types of annuities

  1. Immediate annuity
    • Pay a one-time lump sum premium to the insurer.
    • Start receiving regular income payments immediately - within a month of the investment.
    • Ideal for retirees wanting a regular income source.
  2. Deferred annuity
    • Build a corpus with an insurer to buy an annuity plan upon retirement.
    • Receive regular payments on pre-decided dates.
  3. Fixed annuity
    • Receive guaranteed and regular payments.
    • The insurer sets the interest rate.
    • Enjoy safety and income stability during retirement.
  4. Variable annuity
    • Payments vary based on the chosen investment’s performance.
    • Offers market-linked growth potential but also carries market risk.

Types of pensions

  1. Government employee pensions
    • Eligible central government employees receive a pension upon retirement.
    • Covers the employee up to the date of demise.
    • Can extend to a family pension for dependents after the specific employee’s demise.
  2. National Pension System (NPS)
    • A voluntary, government-backed pension scheme for all employees.
    • Contributions are regularly made by employees during their working years.
    • A lump sum withdrawal of 60% is allowed at retirement, while converting the remaining into an annuity.
  3. Employees’ Provident Fund (EPF)
    • Organized sector employees receive a pension upon retiring after 58.
    • Both employer and employee contribute 12% each of the employee’s salary to EPF, which grows with interest.
    • A portion of the employer’s contribution goes into the Employees’ Pension Scheme (EPS), providing a monthly pension after retirement.
  4. Deferred pension plans
    • Individuals invest regularly during employment.
    • Pension starts after a selected date, generally post-retirement.
    • Suitable for long-term retirement planning.
  5. Immediate pension plans
    • Monthly pension payouts start immediately after you make the lump sum investment.
    • Suitable for those nearing retirement or already retired.
  6. Whole life ULIP pension plans
    • Designed for retirement with the combined benefits of life insurance and pension savings.
    • A portion of the premium is invested in market-linked funds, and the other in life cover.
    • Helps build wealth with retirement security.
  7. Pension plans with life cover
    • Provide retirement income benefits with insurance cover.
    • Ensures the family gets benefits if the policyholder dies.

Annuity vs. NPS – Which One Should I Opt For?

Unable to understand annuity vs NPS - which one to buy? Here’s a summary that can help.

  • A pension is an ideal choice if you want to build a retirement fund gradually through regular savings.
  • Go for a pension fund if you’re salaried, as it suits your steady income stream.
  • Opt for an annuity if you can deposit a lump sum and want a guaranteed income with flexible payout options.
  • If you’re self-employed or your retirement is nearing, annuities can provide peace of mind from your existing corpus.

The decision for the right financial instrument depends on your financial goals, income type, dependents, and risk tolerance. Select the plan most suited to your lifestyle and future needs.

Conclusion

As you can see, both NPS and annuity plans have their own sets of pros and cons. So, when planning for your retirement, choose an investment instrument that suits your unique needs.

If you’re looking for a simple way to get started on your retirement planning investments, download Tata Moneyfy's mutual fund app. Enjoy goal-based investing today.

FAQs

What happens to a 40% annuity in NPS?

In NPS, you can withdraw up to 60% of the accumulated corpus as a lump sum at retirement, while the remaining 40% must be used to purchase an annuity. This annuity provides regular pension payments for the rest of your life.

Which is better, NPS or pension plan?

Choosing between NPs and a traditional pension plan depends on your financial goals and needs. NPS offers tax benefits, flexibility in investment choices, and a combination of lump-sum withdrawal and annuity. It is suitable for those seeking a long-term retirement savings plan with market-linked returns. Traditional pension plans often offer guaranteed returns and fixed monthly payouts but may lack the investment flexibility of NPS.

Is every annuity a pension?

Not every annuity is a pension. An annuity is a financial product that provides regular payments over a specified period, often used for retirement income. While many annuities are designed to serve as pensions, providing income for retirement, some annuities can be structured for other purposes, such as fixed-term payments or lump-sum distributions.

Can we take a 100% annuity from NPS?

Yes. You can invest 100% of your NPS corpus in an annuity plan on superannuation. Doing so may result in higher income payouts after your retirement. However, it may impact liquidity as you will not receive any lump sum at the time of retirement. A more balanced approach is to withdraw a portion of your NPS corpus as a lump sum and invest the remaining in an annuity.

What happens to a 40% annuity in NPS after death?

After the subscriber’s death, the annuity (pension) will be paid to their spouse (if any) for their lifetime. If the spouse is not alive, it will then be paid to the surviving dependent mother or father of the deceased subscriber. Once all such family members have been covered, the original purchase price of the annuity will be returned to the subscriber’s surviving children or legal heir.

Which is the best annuity option in NPS?

NPS allows you to choose from five different annuity options at the time of superannuation. The best annuity option depends on your personal preferences and financial goals. Here’s a simple guide:

  • If you want maximum pension for yourself, choose an annuity for life
  • If you want a pension for your spouse after your death, choose a joint-life annuity
  • If you want financial benefits for your children, choose an annuity with ROP

How many years is the NPS annuity for?

In single premium and immediate annuity plans, the minimum payment term can be 5, 10, 15, or 20 years. After this, the subscriber continues to receive annuity payments for the rest of their life. There are also options to extend annuity payouts to the spouse’s lifetime.

What is better than an annuity for retirement?

Bonds, FDs, mutual funds, dividend-paying stocks, and many others can provide a retirement income. However, annuities are the most popular because of the benefits of a guaranteed income and multiple payout options.

What is the difference between a pension fund and a retirement annuity?

A pension fund allows you to accumulate funds for your retirement by regularly contributing a specific amount into the fund. A retirement annuity requires paying a lump sum to the insurer, who then provides regular payouts at pre-defined intervals or immediately based on your financial requirements.

How does a pension plan differ from an annuity plan?

A pension plan provides post-retirement income. It is either employer-sponsored or purchased individually through various schemes. On the other hand, an annuity plan is purchased from an insurer and gives guaranteed payouts at pre-decided intervals of time.

Should I rely on a pension or buy an annuity for retirement income?

While having a pension is good, it may not be sufficient for your retirement. An annuity provides an additional guaranteed income, which is ideal for self-employed individuals or those retiring with a lump sum of savings.

What is the difference between withdrawing from a pension and an annuity?

Pensions allow a lump sum withdrawal, followed by monthly payouts for the remaining amount. Annuities generally provide regular payouts with no option for lump sum withdrawals once the plan starts.